The short answer
Choose spray foam when you want insulation and air sealing in one step, such as an attic you want to bring inside the conditioned space, a rim joist, a metal building or a room that never stays comfortable. Fiberglass batts or blown-in fiberglass can make sense for open, easy-to-reach attic floors and new walls when air sealing is handled separately.
Many homes use both: spray foam where air leaks and tight spaces matter, fiberglass where there is plenty of room. A good contractor will look at your attic and walls before recommending one.
How each one works
The U.S. Department of Energy lists blanket insulation (batts and rolls) as the most common type in American homes, and describes sprayed or foamed-in-place insulation as two chemicals mixed and sprayed to form polyurethane that can fill even small cavities.
The Spray Polyurethane Foam Alliance says still air is the main insulating medium in open-cell foam, fiberglass and cellulose, but open-cell foam's fine cell structure makes it air-impermeable at certain thicknesses, so it can qualify as an air-barrier material. Fiberglass, by contrast, lets air move through it, which is why air sealing matters so much with batts and blown-in.
Open-cell or closed-cell?
SPFA lists typical R-values of about R-3.6 to R-4.5 per inch for open-cell foam and about R-5.8 to R-6.9 per inch for closed-cell foam. Closed-cell is rigid and water-resistant and is the only spray foam meant for places where contact with water is likely. Open-cell is soft and moisture-permeable, like fiberglass.
In North Texas attics, open-cell foam under the roof deck is a common choice. Closed-cell is often used where space is tight or moisture is a concern, such as rim joists and metal buildings. Ask your installer to explain which foam they recommend for each area and why.
Spray foam vs fiberglass at a glance
General differences only. Your home's layout, ducts and goals decide what fits best.
| Spray foam | Fiberglass (batts or blown-in) | |
|---|---|---|
| Air sealing | Air-impermeable at certain thicknesses, so it seals as it insulates. | Does not stop air movement; gaps and penetrations need separate sealing. |
| R-value per inch (typical) | Open-cell about R-3.6 to R-4.5; closed-cell about R-5.8 to R-6.9 (SPFA). | Varies by product; usually needs more thickness for the same R-value as closed-cell foam. |
| Moisture | Closed-cell resists water; open-cell is moisture-permeable. | Moisture-permeable; loses performance if wet or compressed. |
| Best fits | Roof decks (sealed attics), rim joists, walls with many gaps, metal buildings. | Open attic floors, new stud walls, easy-to-reach spaces. |
| Install | Pro install with protective gear; occupants leave during spraying and curing. | Batts can be DIY; blown-in usually needs a machine. |
| Code items | Usually needs a thermal or ignition barrier depending on location. | Faced batts and attic installs have their own fire and vapor rules. |
No prices are listed here on purpose. Price depends on your home, so request a free quote for an exact number in writing.
What matters for Princeton and Collin County homes
Heat and humidity: long, hot summers put the attic at the center of comfort. If your ducts and air handler sit in the attic, ask whether a sealed (foamed) roof deck is an option, and how the attic would be ventilated or conditioned afterward.
Safety during install: the EPA says occupants should vacate during spray foam installation and stay out until the foam has cured and the area has been ventilated and cleaned. Ask your installer how long they recommend for the product they use.
Code: spray foam inside a home generally needs a thermal barrier such as half-inch drywall, with some exceptions for attics and crawl spaces when conditions are met. Ask who checks this for your project.
Spray foam is usually the better fit when
- Rooms stay hot or drafty even after adding attic insulation.
- Ducts or the air handler sit in a hot attic.
- You are insulating a metal building, shop or barn.
- Walls or rim joists have lots of gaps, wires and pipes.
- Space is tight and you need more R-value per inch.
Fiberglass may be enough when
- The attic floor is open, easy to reach and already air sealed.
- You are insulating new stud walls during construction.
- Your main goal is topping up existing attic insulation.
- Ducts are inside the conditioned space already.
Get your free, exact quote
We don't post prices because every project is different. Tell us about yours and a local pro will give you an exact number, free and with no obligation.
Get my free, exact quote Or call (469) 812-8909
Sources checked 2026-11-15: U.S. DOE: Consumer Guide to Home Insulation (PDF); Spray Polyurethane Foam Alliance: FAQs; U.S. DOE Building America: Which Spray Foam Is Right for You? (PDF).